Europe Wants to Stand

Last year saw a significant re-igniting of the debate of having the choice to stand at football stadiums in English football. After a parliamentary petition passed over 100,000 signatures, it reached the House of Commons for debate by the then Sports Minister Tracey Crouch. The government agreed to collect further data on the issue to formulate a detailed report.

MOMS had ended up at parliament once again on the issue, earlier last year, having previously visited back in 2012 to discuss the issue with MP’s.

Back in 2012, MOMS had asked the assembled MPs what they thought the time-line would be on implementing ‘Safe Standing’, as it was called back then. Seven years on, and there seems to have been minimal movement by parliament on the issue, although the actions of last year certainly have got the ball rolling again.

View this post on Instagram

Safe standing meeting yesterday with MPs and 41 fan reps at parliament, organised by the Shadow Sports Minister (1st pic not by me, I’m in it). It echoed a meeting I attended there six years ago… from numerous surveys and research it’s obvious an overwhelming major of supporters – the people at the heart of the matter – want the choice. Such choice would solve so many issues related to watching the game and is a win-win for everyone. Now, the debate must focus on countering the lazy misconceptions of some MPs, who have an entrenched stance against it, that blocks progressive reform. The 25th June debate in the Commons will be the first opportunity. For example, they need to be reminded that when there are no cage-like FENCES, standing has always been a traditional and a safe way to watch football. #SafeStanding #AVFC

A post shared by My Old Man Said (Aston Villa) (@myoldmansaid) on

The issue of standing at football stadium is not confined just to these isles though, as under UEFA rules, there is a ban on standing at European competition games and internationals.

From this month, football fans from various clubs have started to protest against the UEFA’s outdated ban, under the slogan ‘EUROPE WANTS TO STAND’.

The protests began at the beginning of this month at the Champions League tie between Borussia Dortmund and Tottenham Hotspur.

In addition to banners in the stands, the organisers have written an open letter to UEFA explaining their stance. The letter has been signed by a broad alliance of European fan organisations, as detailed below.

FSE LETTER TO UEFA

Dear Mr Čeferin, 

Members of the UEFA Executive Committee,

21 years ago, UEFA introduced a ban on standing at international matches. In the name of the majority of supporters across the continent, we urge you to reconsider this ban and give us the choice of whether to sit or stand at football matches.

As you are no doubt aware, the standing ban was closely linked to several disasters in European stadia and was intended as a quick solution to improve the safety of spectators. However, a number of long-term evaluations have concluded that the existence of standing sections was NOT the cause of these tragedies.

The fact that it is possible to provide standing sections without safety or security risks at football matches is clearly evident in Germany, where approximately 100,000 fans stand up every weekend to support their team, contributing to the much vaunted atmosphere at Bundesliga matches.

In contrast, the English authorities have tried unsuccessfully to force fans to sit for the past two decades. At every Premier League and Championship game, thousands of fans stand in areas not specifically designed for standing. The situation in Germany is especially absurd, with extra seats having to be installed at a high cost for UEFA club competitions, even though fans end up standing on or between seats anyway.

In addition to the security aspect, the all-seater policy and the associated increase in ticket prices has also led to the exclusion of young and low-income fans, which should neither be underestimated nor ignored by UEFA. It is our belief that stadia must be open to people from all walks of life. The provision of tickets in standing areas is one of the easiest ways to achieve this objective.

On behalf of European fans, we would therefore urge you to re-evaluate UEFA’s position on the all-seater policy. The successful adaptation of the requirements for serving alcoholic beverages has shown that it is possible to provide more fan friendly rules through solutions at a national level.

In several countries, such as Scotland, the Netherlands or France, the strict ban on standing has been lifted in recent years and the same currently is being considered in other countries. We expect UEFA to pick up on these developments. Fan-friendly arrangements at local or national level should not be blocked by UEFA requirements, which are based on outdated evidence.

Best Regards,

Südkurve München / Bündnis Südtribüne Dortmund / Nordwestkurve Frankfurt / Nordkurve Mönchengladbach

Football Supporters Europe

Belgian Supporters (Belgium)

Danske Fodbold Fanklubber (Denmark)

Football Supporters Federation (England)

Association Nationale des Supporters (France)

Pro Fans / Unsere Kurve / Bündnis aktiver Fussball Fans (Germany)

Supporterscollectief Nederland (Netherlands) (Netherlands)

Amalgamation of Official Northern Ireland Supporters’ Clubs (Northern Ireland)

Norsk Supporterallianse (Norway)

Irish Supporters Network (Republic of Ireland)

Federación de Accionistas y Socios del Fútbol Español (Spain)

Svenska Fotbollssupporterunionen (Sweden)

Associação Portuguesa de Defesa do Adepto – APDA (Portugal)

FSF Cymru (Wales)

Listen & subscribe to the MOMS Podcast

My Old Man Said Podcast Spotify
My Old Man Said on Apple Podcasts iTunes